.st0{fill:#FFFFFF;}

Guides

Best Sticker Paper for Making Customized Stickers at Home

 July 26, 2021

By  Jane Melcher

Hiring professionals to make stickers for you can be costly and inconvenient since there isn't a guarantee you'll get exactly what you want. That's why most people are looking for other financially sound methods of making stickers from the comfort of their office or home. If you want to make an ideal sticker for a particular occasion or function, you can make it yourself with the best sticker paper.

This post covers the best sticker papers on the market and the buyer's guide that should inform your decision.

Enjoy!

1. Online Labels White Matte Sticker Paper for Inkjet or Laser Printer

Sticker Paper, 100 Sheets, White Matte, 8.5 x 11 Full Sheet Label, Inkjet or Laser Printer, Online...
  • BLANK WHITE MATTE STICKER PAPER - printable...
  • NO SLITS ON LINER - no slits on backing for...
  • INCLUDED IN ORDER - 100 full sheet 8.5" x 11"...
  • COMMON USES - create DIY sticker sheets,...
  • ACTIVATION CODE TO DESIGN SOFTWARE - every...

The best sticker paper for making your homemade stickers is the Online Labels Sticker paper, a printable and permanent adhesive paper that won't turn yellow. Additionally, thanks to the premium quality build, this printable sticker paper is smudge-proof, meaning you don't have to worry about your prints looking faded.

This sticker paper doesn't feature slits on the backing, making it an ideal selection for those who want full sheets that they can cut with a Cricut machine or Silhouette Cameo. So, you can rest assured that it's compatible with various cutting machines.

Something unique about this purchase is that you'll get a free activation code on the packing slip using the Maestro Label Designer from Online Labels. As such, you can create your own designs for planner stickers, product labels, and other stickers.

These matte white sticker papers will permanently stick to metal, glass, cardboard, glass, and other surfaces for a professional look. You'll be glad to know that the package comes in a plastic clamshell casing which protects the sticker papers during shipping. Plus, the casing provides a neat way to store the papers when you are not using them.

Pros

  • Strong adhesion.
  • Great print quality.
  • Compatible with inkjet and laser printers.
  • Easy to use.
  • Smudge-proof.

Cons

  • The backing looks identical to the printer paper.


2. Printable Vinyl Sticker Paper for Inkjet Printer

Printable Vinyl Sticker Paper for Inkjet Printer - Glossy White - 15 Self-Adhesive Sheets -...
  • High-Quality Printable Vinyl Paper - set...
  • Self-Adhesive and Water-Resistant Stickers -...
  • Scratch and Tear Resistant Paper - our...
  • Compatible With Most Inkjet Printers -...
  • Endless possibilities for your creativity -...

Next, we have the Printable Vinyl Sticker Paper from Limia's Care Store, which offers unlimited possibilities for making stickers. This sticker paper can is great for various DIY projects like creating bumper stickers, vinyl stickers for laptops, car decals, and murals. The only application this paper is unsuitable for is printing on t-shirts.

The high-quality vinyl paper can produce images with impeccable resolution and clarity to ensure your stickers look like they were made by experts. These vinyl sheets come with a glossy finish to ensure they are water-resistant, which means they are durable. You can therefore use them for indoor or outdoor labels without any worries.

Even when you remove these self-adhesive stickers, they won't leave a sticky residue on the surface. As such, you can use them and remove them without destroying the appearance of the plastic, wood, metal, or glass surface.

Pros

  • Prints vibrant colors.
  • Glossy appearance.
  • Scratch and tear-resistant.
  • Water-resistant.

Cons

  • Not suitable for t-shirts.


3. Neato Labels Clear Sticker Paper

Sale
Clear Sticker Paper - Vinyl Full Sheet Label - Weatherproof - for Inkjet and Laser Printers - 10...
  • CLEAR VINYL STICKER PAPER: IMPROVED MATERIAL...
  • INKJET & LASER PRINTER COMPATIBLE: These...
  • PRODUCT SPECIFICATIONS: Package contains 10...
  • FREE DESIGN SOFTWARE: We include and...
  • CRAFT CUTTING MACHINES - The labels have no...

If you are looking for weatherproof and clear sticker paper for your projects, this Neato product is a great option. This transparent sticker paper offers a wide range of possibilities for customization. The only limit to what you can make with this item is your imagination since every detail will be up to you to decide.

Since it's compatible with any inkjet and laser printer, you can comfortably use it with the one you have available. Plus, it also works with all cutting machines, including the Cricut machine and silhouette cutting tools.

While this sticker paper is weatherproof, you'll still need to print on them with UV ink and apply UV-resistant sealer spray to ensure they are waterproof. Fortunately, even exposure to the elements won't compromise the durable nature of this clear sticker paper.

Something else that makes this item one of the best sticker papers is the free design software included to make it easier to print your sheets.

Pros

  • Weatherproof.
  • Great adhesion.
  • Easy to use.
  • Ideal print quality.
  • Versatile.

Cons

  • Easily smudges.


4. Avery Printable Glossy Sticker Paper

Sale
Avery Printable Sticker Paper, Glossy Clear, 8.5" x 11", Laser & Inkjet Printers, 7 Sheets (4397)
  • This full sheet printable sticker paper gives...
  • Avery glossy, clear sticker paper is great to...
  • Stick and stay; the sticker paper has an...
  • The glossy clear project sticker paper is...

Next, we have the Avery Sticker Paper, a full sheet sticker paper that allows you to create stickers and labels of any shape, size, or design for a customized look. Fortunately, the Avery brand has various styles available to ensure you can find the perfect fit for your project. You can choose between matte white, glossy clear, or kraft brown, depending on your preferences.

Whether you want to make stickers or labels for your books, ingredient containers, or water bottles, this is the kind of sticker paper you want. This paper also makes excellent die-cut stickers if that's something you are interested in. You can tailor the shapes of the stickers with a die-cutting machine or scissors depending on what you have available.

You can also use your laser or inkjet printer for this sticker paper for whatever designs you want to make. Plus, if you need creative inspiration for the designs, you can find free customizable templates at the Avery website after your purchase.

Pros

  • Slits on the backing paper.
  • Removable adhesive backing.
  • Sticks well.
  • Works with laser and inkjet printers.
  • Compatible with any cutting machine.

Cons

  • Not very clear.
  • Not waterproof.


5. Cricut Sticker Paper

Cricut Printable Vinyl, White
  • For use with ink jet printers and the print,...
  • Choose the custom setting "Printable Vinyl"...
  • Remove excess vinyl with the Cricut Tools...
  • Keep printed images dry to preserve longevity

In fifth place, we have the Cricut Sticker Paper, which is the best sticker paper for scrapbooking. If you'd prefer a brand-specific sticker-making experience, you can use this sticker paper alongside your Cricut Explore machine.

You can create your designs using Cricut Design Space software for an easier process. With more than 5,000 images to inspire your stickers, you can rest assured that the Cricut Image Library will have all that you need.

The Cricut Printable Vinyl allows you to make full-color decals that feature a smooth matte finish for a professional look. As you use this printable sticker paper on the Cricut machine, you can choose the printable vinyl setting to ensure the backing is left uncut, making it easier to stick your decals.

These sticker papers are meant for use with an inkjet printer and can create high-quality resolution images that will last long. You can use them for various items like decor projects, handmade gifts, and holiday decorations.

Pros

  • Easy to use.
  • Ideal adhesion.
  • Removable.
  • No smearing or smudge.

Cons

  • Easy for the sticker paper to jam.


6. iLable Full Sheet Sticker Paper

iLable 8.5" x 11" Full Sheet Sticker Paper for Laser & Inkjet Printers[100 Sheets,100 Labels]
  • 【SPECIFICATIONS】Each Label Size:8.5" x...
  • 【NO SLITS ON LINER】no slits on backing...
  • 【JAM FREE】iLabels are powerful adhesive...
  • 【Quality First】Quality control by iLabel...
  • 【FREE TEMPLATES】Printing templates and...

The next best sticker paper for your home projects is the iLable Full Sheet Sticker Paper. It's a standard letter size sticker paper that has a durable quality. In the package, you'll receive 100 white paper labels which will meet your sticker-making needs appropriately.

Unlike regular sticker paper, this one comes without any slits, which means that you can use it with various cutting machines like Cricut Joy or Silhouette. This means that you can control the shape the stickers will take for a customized look.

You don't have to worry about these sticker sheets jamming your printer. They are designed with the right weight and thickness to ensure they go through your printing machine as smoothly as possible. The adhesive on this sticker paper will provide long-lasting results and will stick tightly to any surface you choose.

Plus, as any good sticker paper should, this one will deliver a high print quality with your designs looking just as you imagined. The front side and backing paper don't look the same, which helps avoid confusion as you load them into your printer.

Pros

  • Easy to use.
  • High-quality prints.
  • Permanent adhesion.

Cons

  • Not ideal for kiss cuts.


7. ZICOTO Printable Vinyl Sticker Paper

Premium Printable Vinyl Sticker Paper for Your Inkjet Or Laser Printer - 15 Glossy White Waterproof...
3,520 Reviews
Premium Printable Vinyl Sticker Paper for Your Inkjet Or Laser Printer - 15 Glossy White Waterproof...
  • Water-Resistant Vinyl Sticker Paper: With the...
  • Highly Durable Printable Sticker Paper:...
  • Compatible With Your Inkjet Printer: The...
  • DIY Personalized Stickers: Get creative with...
  • Easy Application & Quick Drying: The...

Another great pick among the best sticker paper options is the Premium Printable Vinyl Sticker Paper by ZICOTO. This waterproof sticker paper will serve your needs whether you want to apply them indoors or outdoors. However, to ensure maximum waterproofing, we recommend adding a layer of UV-resistant coating to give it the durability you want.

You can use this sticker paper to make planner stickers, labels, and decals, depending on your preferences. Since it's glossy sticker paper, you can get as creative as you'd like to make stickers for home or professional use.

Since it's compatible with inkjet printers, it'll absorb the ink naturally to give you high-resolution prints that will make you look like a sticker-making expert. Once you apply the ink on these glossy stickers, it'll dry within minimal time and give you stunning results.

The sticker papers are thick and durable, making them a great choice out of many options currently on the market.

Pros

  • Quality adhesion.
  • Decent print quality.
  • Water resistance.
  • Long-lasting.

Cons

  • Not ideal for t-shirt application.


Factors to Consider When Buying the Best Sticker Paper

1. Type of Printer

Before choosing your sticker papers, you'll want to ensure they are compatible with your current printer. There are two main printers you can use on sticker papers; inkjet and laser printers. Unfortunately, some papers are strictly designed to work with only one type of printer, which can limit your flexibility to use them.

For the best results, you'll want to go with the ones that are compatible with both laser and inkjet printers. However, you can select one that corresponds to your sticker papers without any hassle. Even though the paper can affect the quality of the final product, the printer you have and the ink you use have a lot to say about it.

2. Water Resistance

Water resistance is a crucial feature for sticker papers since water can easily damage the color and clarity of your images. This is especially essential if you want to make stickers for an outdoor application like making bumper stickers. If you are taking the stickers outside where they can be exposed to the elements, you don't want to buy normal copy paper since it won't last long.

As such, you want to go with a thick and durable sticker paper that can handle outdoor conditions without fading or tearing. This means you should go with a weatherproof sticker paper that can withstand UV rays, wind, and direct rainfall. In doing so, you'll have a long-lasting option that will conveniently serve your needs.

3. Adhesion

When considering the type of paper you want, you should also look at the type of adhesive it uses. Some papers come with permanent adhesives, making them a great choice for making stickers that you won't want to change for a long while. Unfortunately, these sticker papers don't allow you to remove them from the surface you apply them on since they stick permanently.

If you want temporary stickers to remove or change up as time goes, you should choose a paper with temporary adhesives. These stickers allow you to remove them from the surface without tearing or ripping them apart. They leave the area clean so that you can apply another sticker if you want to.

4. Cutting Machine Compatibility

The last thing to keep in mind in your search for the right paper for your stickers is the cutting machine you have. Firstly, there are two ways you can cut stickers from a full sheet; with scissors or an electronic cutting machine.

If you have something like Cricut maker, you'll want to check the product description for compatibility with the machine. You don't want to get a paper that you can conveniently cut with the tools you have available, which is why you'll want to ensure it can work with the machine you have.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What is the best sticker paper to use for stickers?

The best sticker paper on the market is the Online Labels White Matte Sticker Paper for Inkjet or Laser Printer.

2. What is the best paper to use for stickers on Cricut?

If you have a Cricut machine, the best paper sticker to use is the Cricut sticker paper designed to work seamlessly with the cutting machine.

3. What is the best printable vinyl for stickers?

The Limia's Care Store Printable Vinyl Sticker Paper for Inkjet Printer is the best option if you want a printable vinyl option.

Jane Melcher


Jane is a stay-at-home small business mom. She makes more than her husband selling her creations on Etsy.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}